Written and collected by Zia H Shah MD, with the help of ChatGPT

Introduction

Interpreting the Qur’an correctly is one of the most pressing responsibilities for Muslims today. As a living scripture believed to be God’s word for all times, the Qur’an requires an approach to interpretation that is dynamic, holistic, and context-aware. Progressive Muslim scholars argue that treating the Qur’an as a “dead” text with fixed meanings from centuries past not only does injustice to its message, but also contradicts the very notion of a Living God who guides humans in every age thequran.love thequran.love. The best way to interpret the Qur’an, therefore, is to blend deep reverence with thoughtful analysis – letting its eternal principles shine while remaining mindful of language, context, and evolving human understanding.

In this article, we explore an interpretive methodology rooted in thematic insights from the Qur’an itself and the commentaries of scholar Zia H. Shah MD and others. This method is at once religiously faithful and academically rigorous, making it well-suited for progressive Muslims seeking to live by the Qur’an’s guidance in the modern world. We will discuss how to discern the Qur’an’s fundamental teachings, what sources and criteria to use in exegesis, and why context and metaphor are crucial. Along the way, we will see how this approach avoids the pitfalls of literalism that lead to division or extremism, and instead unlocks the Quranic message of compassion, justice, and wisdom for our time.

A Living Text for a Living God

One cornerstone of progressive Qur’an interpretation is the belief that God is “Ever-Living” (Al-Ḥayy) and so His message must speak to each era. In practical terms, this means rejecting the notion that understanding of the Qur’an was forever frozen by classical scholars. As one writer notes, “When any religious person claims that a sacred text’s meaning is fixed forever – essentially ‘dead’ – they are directly at odds with their own idea of a living, active God.” thequran.love If God is alive and all-knowing, then surely He anticipated new knowledge and circumstances; He “knew then what we know now,” and intends for us to use all knowledge available to us when pondering His words thequran.love thequran.love.

In other words, interpreting the Qur’an as a “living” document honors God’s omniscience, whereas treating it as a static relic would imply (astaghfirullah) a “dead” deity unable to engage with changing times thequran.love. The Qur’an itself claims to be “intended for all times and all places,” a universal message (Muhammad Abdel Haleem’s words)thequran.love. Thus, the best interpretation approach welcomes fresh insights and adapts to new contexts, trusting that the living God who authored the Qur’an guides readers to ever-deepening understanding.

Crucially, this does not mean distorting scripture to suit whims. It means seeking the timeless spirit behind the text’s time-bound letter. Progressive scholars insist that God’s core commands – justice, benevolence, use of reason – are eternally valid, while certain social or legal directives addressed to 7th-century Arabs may require reinterpretation today. The Qur’an itself cautions against blind adherence to tradition: “When they are told, ‘Follow what God has sent down,’ they say, ‘Nay, we follow what we found our forefathers doing.’ Why, even if their forefathers used no reason at all?” (Qur’an 2:170) thequran.love. In this spirit, a living interpretation favors principle over precedent – it values what Allah actually revealed over how past humans understood it thequran.love. God did not cease engaging with humanity after the 7th century; as one author quips, if earlier scholars were alive today, “of course” they would re-read God’s words using all the information we now have, rather than limit themselves to their own 1000-year-old writings thequran.love.

By approaching the Qur’an as a dynamic, living guide, we maintain “allegiance to the Living God” rather than to the literal interpretations of bygone humans thequran.love. This makes our tafsir (exegesis) a continuing dialogue with the Divine, ever seeking the broader wisdom God placed in the Qur’an for each new age.

Read further in Microsoft Word file: