Written and collected by Zia H Shah MD

Belief in an All-Knowing, All-Seeing God – a God who is aware of every action and will hold us accountable – can have a profound transformative impact on human behavior. Across psychology experiments, philosophical reflections, and theological teachings, we find converging evidence that the sense of being watched and accountable drives people toward honesty, self-restraint, and moral improvement. While people of no faith can certainly live ethical lives on the strength of conscience alone, believers carry an additional inner observer – the conviction of a divine presence that monitors intentions and deeds themuslimtimes.info. This article will explore how that conviction can positively change hearts and minds, in subtle contrast to other beliefs (for example, relying on someone else’s sacrifice for forgiveness) that by themselves may not directly inspire the same moral transformation. We will draw on a remarkable New Zealand experiment highlighted by Morgan Freeman, insights from Dr. Zia H. Shah, relevant Quranic and Hadith quotes, and findings from psychology and philosophy to understand this phenomenon.

The Princess Alice Experiment: An Invisible Watcher and Child Honesty

One powerful illustration comes from a New Zealand study featured by actor Morgan Freeman in The Story of God documentary series. In this experiment led by psychologist Jesse Bering at the University of Otago, young children were told an invisible person named “Princess Alice” was in the room with them. The children then played a game where they had the opportunity to cheat when the adult left the room. Remarkably, those who believed in the invisible presence were far less likely to cheat pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. In fact, if a child truly accepted Princess Alice was watching, it deterred cheating about as effectively as if a real adult were present in the room pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. Morgan Freeman’s documentary segment (season 1, episode 5, ~32 minutes in) showcases how even a pretend belief in an unseen observer made 6-year-olds more honest themuslimtimes.info. The researcher observed the children via hidden camera: those who trusted that Princess Alice was “watching” would hesitate, look over their shoulder, and often refrain from breaking the rules, whereas children who were skeptical of the invisible princess were quicker to peek or cheat once alone pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.

This simple but clever experiment demonstrates a profound psychological truth: our behavior changes when we think we are being watched. Just as the imaginary Princess Alice curbed the children’s dishonesty, a genuine belief in an All-Seeing God can likewise elevate a person’s conduct and character themuslimtimes.info. Dr. Zia H. Shah notes that theists benefit from this extra moral safeguard – an ever-watchful divine presence – which can motivate them toward honesty beyond what personal conscience alone might achieve themuslimtimes.info. Of course, this effect depends on the belief being sincere and internalized. A superficial or merely habitual belief in God’s watchfulness may not suffice; it is the deeply felt faith – the vivid awareness in one’s heart that “I am seen and will answer for my actions” – that truly shapes character and choices thequran.love. When such faith is present, it can inspire even very young children (in the Princess Alice case) to do the right thing, and, by extension, can inspire adults to live by higher moral standards.

Read further in Microsoft Word file: