Written and collected by Zia H Shah MD

Abstract

A curious legend tells of Martin Luther “buying Hell” from a Catholic priest and promptly declaring it closed to the public. This tale – often recounted in popular and satirical narratives – has no known basis in documented history, yet it resonates deeply with the themes of the Protestant Reformation. This paper investigates the origin and meaning of the “Luther bought Hell” legend, examining whether it emerged as satire, folklore, or metaphor. We find that the story likely began as a satirical allegory rather than an event Luther himself claimed, encapsulating in humorous form Luther’s protest against the sale of indulgences and the Church’s claimed authority over salvation. To illuminate the legend’s significance, we discuss the historical context of indulgences and Luther’s theology of free grace, which rejected the notion that Heaven or Hell could be sold or bargained for. Finally, we analyze how this legend has been interpreted over time – from Reformation-era symbolism to modern retellings – and how it reflects the broader narrative of Luther “shutting the gates of hell” by liberating believers from the fear-based control of the medieval Church. An epilogue offers a thematic reflection on the power of such legends in shaping the memory and symbolism of the Reformation.

Read further in Microsoft Word file: