Written and collected by Zia H Shah MD

Abstract

This commentary examines Qur’an 41:9–12 in depth, exploring its scientific, philosophical, and theological implications. It demonstrates that these verses, when properly understood, do not conflict with the modern scientific timeline (a ~13.8 billion-year-old universe and a ~4.5 billion-year-old Earth). We analyze the Arabic wording and structure of the passage – notably the use of the conjunction thumma (“then” or “furthermore”) – which is key to understanding the sequencing of creation events in these verses. Insights from classical Islamic exegesis (tafsīr) and modern scholars (including Dr. Maurice Bucaille and Muhammad Asad) are incorporated, showing how Muslim scholarship has long reconciled the Qur’anic account of creation with scientific knowledge. Common criticisms related to these verses (such as the misconception that they imply eight days of creation or that the Earth was fully formed before the heavens) are addressed and resolved. The commentary highlights how Qur’an 41:9–12, far from being scientifically problematic, can be seen as mirroring key scientific concepts – for example, the primordial “smoke” (gaseous nebula) of the early universe – and presenting a logically ordered creation narrative. Philosophically and theologically, this analysis underscores the Quran’s purposeful language that speaks effectively to a 7th-century audience yet remains remarkably relevant in the era of modern cosmology. An epilogue reflects on the broader implications of harmonizing Qur’anic revelation with contemporary scientific understanding and classical scholarship.

Read further in PDF file: